20 Comments
Apr 6Liked by Joel J Miller

It would have been interesting to include Fundamentalist Christian American views of Lewis. I grew up closely adjacent to Fundamentalism - never totally immersed because my parents were far too moderate. But growing up in that milieu, outsiders to our family made us children feel very guilty for reading even Christian fantasy authors like Lewis and Tolkien, much less secular fairy tales. To these people, the presence of magic in a book automatically made it demonic and its author must perforce also be Satanic, no matter the author's own stated faith.

'Out of the Silent Planet' is one of my favorite Lewis novels, next to 'Till We Have Faces'. Lewis perfectly captures the tone of the great early science fiction authors like Verne and Wells, and tips the genre on its head to make some profound statements about the impact of the Fall and the Incarnation on the created universe without ever losing the sense of curious wonder that made early science fiction novels literary classics. While the two successive Space Trilogy novels also have profound statements to make, Lewis makes the mistake of letting the message drive the narrative rather than vice versa, making them lesser works, though still well worth reading.

Expand full comment
author

I think I agree on the Space Trilogy. I’ve read all the books twice at this point but not closely. Opinions differ but I also found Perelandra inferior to Out of the Silent Planet. I’m thinking of rereading That Hideous Strength again soon, but my memory is that the books is a bit of a mess :) Lewis himself abridged it (The Tortured Planet), though the shorter version never caught on.

Expand full comment
Apr 6Liked by Joel J Miller

When the Narnia films came out in Germany the press warned their readers that this is the work of a Christian (fundamentalism! Danger!) and might include Christian symbolism -- as an American who was transported by Narnia as a kid I was outraged and frustrated at this concerted effort to destroy such a great work if fantasy before German kids could even get to know it.

This excellent article reminded me that Lewis originally known and controversial as a religious thinker and now I think that’s what stodgy German critics were thinking of.

It was too bad. Not only Narnia has so much to offer but his Christian philosophy works too. Thanks for this review I didn’t know how he was received in Ameriprise to Narnia.

Expand full comment
author

I was totally unaware of that! Thanks for sharing. I’d love to learn more about how Lewis was received in other countries.

Expand full comment
Apr 7Liked by Joel J Miller

I'm no expert, I was just shocked when a good German friend of mine – highly educated, liberal – wouldn't let his kids watch the movies because he'd read something about hidden Christian symbolism in a prominent newspaper – it reminded me of the 80s when mu conservative sister sent me a list of Rock n Rollers I shouldn't listen to because of hidden Satanic symbolism in lyrics and album covers.

Expand full comment
author

The funny thing about that is that you’ve got both “sides” here worried about “hidden symbols.”

Expand full comment
Apr 6Liked by Joel J Miller

Having recently read “The Abolition of Man” I can attest to its applicability to current context. Technocracy, trans-humanism, globalism et al are seen clearly for what they are through the lens of this book.

Expand full comment
author

Abolition has had a long afterlife: https://www.millersbookreview.com/p/voices-of-the-past

Expand full comment

I'm one of the secular scholars: CS Lewis has wit, self-knowledge, deep understanding of what has been written before, and is a codex of the third generation of modernism.

And a tail.

Expand full comment

This was so interesting! Thank you.

Expand full comment
author

My pleasure! Glad you enjoyed it.

Expand full comment
Apr 6Liked by Joel J Miller

I really like your essays on Lewis - you aren't afraid to point out some of his failings. He was human, after all! This is off-topic, but aren't those vintage Time Magazine covers awesome? Every time I see one, I'm impressed.

Expand full comment
author

Thanks! I’ve been reading Lewis since my late teens, and I’ve enjoyed most of his work, particularly his essays and literary scholarship. He’s a great person to think with.

Expand full comment
Apr 6·edited Apr 6Liked by Joel J Miller

I could never find it now, but I recollect long ago seeing a Catholic book from the 1950s on the subject of the Index and proper and improper reading material for Catholics in general, which asserted that Protestant religious writings in general were to be avoided but that some such as those of "Charles [sic] S. Lewis" had received general Catholic approval.

Expand full comment
author

That’s wild. Thanks for sharing!

Expand full comment

Great overview! I still am irked by Lewis's "picayune view of the Church." After a time of almost hero worship I saw the flaws in his cafeteria Christian philosophy as evidenced in how he lived his life. You can't be a "mere" christian and decide for yourself what denomination suits you. You have to find the true Church which is the Body of Christ and suit yourself to the revelation transmitted by the indwelling of the Holy Spirit. After I came back to the Catholic Church it seemed to me that Lewis's essays often wrestle with questions answered by the Church and that were inadequately answered by the intelligence of one individual. That said, I love his space trilogy, because he is not writing about empty space but about the heavens, which are populated by angels and demons, as he imaginatively and brilliantly portrayed.

Expand full comment
author

Ha! I guess some of those issues were left unresolved, no? I think one of the benefits Lewis offers regardless of the tradition one might be in—including those outside any faith tradition—is a track to think along.

Expand full comment
Apr 6Liked by Joel J Miller

I'm looking forward to carving out a bit of quiet time to sit with this article. It looks to be intriguing, rich, and informative. Thank you, Joel ...

Expand full comment
author

Thanks, Linda. And thanks for reading! Noll has given us a pretty fascinating book here.

Expand full comment
deletedApr 6
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
author

That would be great!

Expand full comment