Happy to read this review after more than a decade since reading these myself. I know Silence is considered his masterpiece, but The Samurai has stuck with me much more. For someone raised in Christianity, it for the first time helped me to see and understand "the foolishness of the cross."
I agree. I thought The Samurai was the superior novel, though Ioved them both and probably wouldn’t have come it without reading Silence first. I was so moved by them, I ended up reading them both twice.
These were a first for me. I know very little about this period. I’d heard good things about Silence for years, but put off reading it until I made it part of this 2023 goal. It was so compelling I jumped right into The Samurai. They pair together perfectly.
You are in for a real treat with A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. I once read to a group of women in a local retirement facility and chose that novel as a personal favorite. You wouldn't believe how much these 80+ year old women, all from Montana loved this book. I'm looking forward to the two Japanese Christian books having just finished re-reading In The House of Brede. Thanks for being there, Joel!!!
Thanks for reading! I’ve heard that about A Tree Grows in Brooklyn from several people! I’m going to wait a week before I start it. I’ve got a trip coming up and I’m thinking I’ll start it on the plane. Seems like the perfect plane book :)
After reading Silence, I read Makoto Fujimura's terrific commentary on it: Silence and Beauty. Highly recommended! In 2016 I spent a lovely two hours in a Princeton cafe talking to Mako about his book and related subjects.
I plan to read Samurai. I came across an article on Samurai in Mexico a few years ago and the idea has always fascinated me. I can see a very cool Western being made from that notion. Both of these books sound intriguing.
They both have dark elements, but I didn’t really want The Samurai to end. The experience of the Velasco and the samurai are both so vivid and fully realized, it feels abrupt to end it.
Hello Joel. I am introduced to so many good books through your reviews. I may not get to all of them (so many books, so little time!), but, at least, I am more knowledgeable about the many wonderful authors and cultures out there, and will be more familiar when my and those books' paths cross again.
I very much appreciate the cultural diversity of your chosen books, and their and well-written reviews. Thank you. Mmerikani
Thank you Mmerikani! I’m so glad the reviews have been helpful to you. It’s reading books like Silence and The Samurai that help widen the world for me!
Without this review, I don't think I would've ever read Silence. I watched the movie in parts on various plane rides and didn't know it was based on a novel. What an amazing work of art. I just finished it today and plan on reading Samurai soon. Endo's constant references to the silence that surrounds Rodrigues really stood out to me, as did the struggle with coming to terms with Judas' betrayal. Every Easter I have a discussion with my parents over the fate of Judas, and every Easter I leave that discussion disappointed. This novel was perfect for me in articulating what I have always had trouble forming into words. Thank you for recommending!
I've been reading your substack for a while now, Joel, and enjoying it greatly. I put off reading this particular post until I'd finished The Samurai. I'd read Silence a couple of times over the years, but Samurai has been sitting on my shelf and on this year's 'to-read' list until now. I find them both fascinating. They narratively portray some profound theological questions. The conundrum of persecution and apostasy in Silence in particular. The Samurai with futility and purpose, true and false faith, and fatalism and destiny. And they are so well written. Also they hold the savor of Japan so well, and the peculiar relationship between Japan and Catholicism.
Thank you so much for reviewing these books. I read 'Silence' (no italics are possible here yet) a couple of years ago. (My copy was from Picador Classics, with a large red sun on the cover above Mt. Fuji.)
At the time, as well, during an MFA program, my research went into Dejima - the island to which foreigners were mostly confined for over 200 years outside of Nagasaki - as well as the Portuguese and the Dutch in Japan during this period. Here, in Leiden (the Netherlands), there is a botanical garden and a museum filled with plants and artefacts from a somewhat later period. The first known Japanese elm outside of Japan is here, as are many other 'firsts' from this period before the country opened its doors (or rather, had them forced open by the US).
Charles C. Mann's '1493' does go into the Japanese and many other nations which went into the great mix which was Mexico during colonial times. Will have to get to 'The Samurai' at some point.
The books you are selecting are of such quality, including 'Their Eyes Were Watching God,' which we also read for an African American literature course during the writing degree.
I did wonder, at points, whether the author's search may have been thwarted, or delayed, by holding to organized religion . . . humanity, and its promise, may in great part lie outside of these formal categories.
The small notes of value, where they appear, add to the discussion.
Happy to read this review after more than a decade since reading these myself. I know Silence is considered his masterpiece, but The Samurai has stuck with me much more. For someone raised in Christianity, it for the first time helped me to see and understand "the foolishness of the cross."
I agree. I thought The Samurai was the superior novel, though Ioved them both and probably wouldn’t have come it without reading Silence first. I was so moved by them, I ended up reading them both twice.
This sound so good! I love historical novels but have never read one about this era.
These were a first for me. I know very little about this period. I’d heard good things about Silence for years, but put off reading it until I made it part of this 2023 goal. It was so compelling I jumped right into The Samurai. They pair together perfectly.
You are in for a real treat with A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. I once read to a group of women in a local retirement facility and chose that novel as a personal favorite. You wouldn't believe how much these 80+ year old women, all from Montana loved this book. I'm looking forward to the two Japanese Christian books having just finished re-reading In The House of Brede. Thanks for being there, Joel!!!
Thanks for reading! I’ve heard that about A Tree Grows in Brooklyn from several people! I’m going to wait a week before I start it. I’ve got a trip coming up and I’m thinking I’ll start it on the plane. Seems like the perfect plane book :)
After reading Silence, I read Makoto Fujimura's terrific commentary on it: Silence and Beauty. Highly recommended! In 2016 I spent a lovely two hours in a Princeton cafe talking to Mako about his book and related subjects.
How delightful would that be?! I’ve seen Fujimura’s book; I’ve got to get it.
Hey Joel, I know it seems blasphemous to say, but I appreciated Mako's book more than Endo's in many ways. You would love it!
That’s high praise!
I plan to read Samurai. I came across an article on Samurai in Mexico a few years ago and the idea has always fascinated me. I can see a very cool Western being made from that notion. Both of these books sound intriguing.
They both have dark elements, but I didn’t really want The Samurai to end. The experience of the Velasco and the samurai are both so vivid and fully realized, it feels abrupt to end it.
Hello Joel. I am introduced to so many good books through your reviews. I may not get to all of them (so many books, so little time!), but, at least, I am more knowledgeable about the many wonderful authors and cultures out there, and will be more familiar when my and those books' paths cross again.
I very much appreciate the cultural diversity of your chosen books, and their and well-written reviews. Thank you. Mmerikani
Thank you Mmerikani! I’m so glad the reviews have been helpful to you. It’s reading books like Silence and The Samurai that help widen the world for me!
Without this review, I don't think I would've ever read Silence. I watched the movie in parts on various plane rides and didn't know it was based on a novel. What an amazing work of art. I just finished it today and plan on reading Samurai soon. Endo's constant references to the silence that surrounds Rodrigues really stood out to me, as did the struggle with coming to terms with Judas' betrayal. Every Easter I have a discussion with my parents over the fate of Judas, and every Easter I leave that discussion disappointed. This novel was perfect for me in articulating what I have always had trouble forming into words. Thank you for recommending!
I've been reading your substack for a while now, Joel, and enjoying it greatly. I put off reading this particular post until I'd finished The Samurai. I'd read Silence a couple of times over the years, but Samurai has been sitting on my shelf and on this year's 'to-read' list until now. I find them both fascinating. They narratively portray some profound theological questions. The conundrum of persecution and apostasy in Silence in particular. The Samurai with futility and purpose, true and false faith, and fatalism and destiny. And they are so well written. Also they hold the savor of Japan so well, and the peculiar relationship between Japan and Catholicism.
Thanks so much for this review.
Thank you so much for reviewing these books. I read 'Silence' (no italics are possible here yet) a couple of years ago. (My copy was from Picador Classics, with a large red sun on the cover above Mt. Fuji.)
At the time, as well, during an MFA program, my research went into Dejima - the island to which foreigners were mostly confined for over 200 years outside of Nagasaki - as well as the Portuguese and the Dutch in Japan during this period. Here, in Leiden (the Netherlands), there is a botanical garden and a museum filled with plants and artefacts from a somewhat later period. The first known Japanese elm outside of Japan is here, as are many other 'firsts' from this period before the country opened its doors (or rather, had them forced open by the US).
Charles C. Mann's '1493' does go into the Japanese and many other nations which went into the great mix which was Mexico during colonial times. Will have to get to 'The Samurai' at some point.
The books you are selecting are of such quality, including 'Their Eyes Were Watching God,' which we also read for an African American literature course during the writing degree.
I did wonder, at points, whether the author's search may have been thwarted, or delayed, by holding to organized religion . . . humanity, and its promise, may in great part lie outside of these formal categories.
The small notes of value, where they appear, add to the discussion.
This is a great initiative.