17 Comments
Mar 25, 2023Liked by Joel J Miller

I could talk for days about this book, although my first foray into anything Austen was in fact the 1940s movie which is very different in many respects but retains the delightful verbal combat between Darcy and Elizabeth. (When I first read P&P I was confused when it turned out Lady Catherine was in fact just a terrible person and not giving Elizabeth a Secret Test Of Character.)

Re: the Church of England filter, they basically had no filter. Becoming a clergyman was one of the few "gentleman" occupations available and it became more of a holding place for younger sons vs. anything resembling a calling. (Something Austen touches on in Mansfield Park.)

I advise you immediately go and read all the rest. Sense and Sensibility also has some "spit your tea out" lines.

Expand full comment
author

I’m definitely eyeing Sense and Sensibilty.

Re talking for days about the book: I get that. I’ve found that people who have read the book are nearly always super fans. There are those who (a) haven’t read it and (b) love it madly, and there aren’t that many people in between.

Expand full comment
Mar 25, 2023Liked by Joel J Miller

My favorite novel of all time. I've re-read it so many times and always come away with a smile or chuckle. Like Wodehouse she is a master of the mot juste. Austen's "Emma" is another good one, but can't quite equal P and P (at least for me). Of all her novels I think that "Northanger Abbey" and "Manfield Park" don't have quite the humor and the characters are not quite as well drawn--or perhaps, are less likeable. (At least for me.) I'm so glad you got around to P and P and enjoyed it so very much.

Expand full comment
author

Yes, so many lines in the book land exactly right. And (at least at first reading) they’re often unexpected. Where did she come up with that stuff? It’s like that letter to her sister—her sense of humor was a deep (and slightly impish) well.

Expand full comment
Mar 25, 2023Liked by Joel J Miller

Loved your take on Austen. She is hysterical. I remember that’s what surprised me most about her when I first read Emma. The way she develops characters and uses humor to point out the ridiculous social expectations of the time is so insightful and clever. I’m so glad you enjoyed this one!

Expand full comment
Mar 27, 2023Liked by Joel J Miller

Picked up the annotated version earlier this year because, gasp, I’ve never read any Austin and this post has encouraged me to get started!

Expand full comment

Lizzie Bennett is one of the great characters in all of literature. What a book.

Expand full comment
author

I found her enjoyable from her first utterance. She’s funny, frank, and self-critical. I wish I was more like that.

Expand full comment
Jun 30, 2023Liked by Joel J Miller

Yes! I always hoped that I would grow up to be Lizzie... still hoping.

Expand full comment

Well done sir. I sent this to Karen Swallow Prior and told her how much she would enjoy reading you... and she told me you were her editor on a prior book! So, I'm late to that party! Great review Joel.

Expand full comment
author

Yes! I got to work with her on Fierce Convictions, her biography of Hannah More. That was almost ten years ago now!

Expand full comment

I love Pride and Prejudice so much that I dedicated my very first proper post on Substack to it! 🤞Fingers crossed the next generation is as enamored with it as I have been.

Expand full comment

I’m behind on my classics goal. Good reminder!

Expand full comment
author

No worries. There are no goal police. Just catch up as you can. What are you reading this month?

Expand full comment

I have Treasure Island in my sights ... but I haven't started yet.

Expand full comment

Oh, Treasure Island is a rich and wonderful story. Stevenson’s genius for original storytelling is fully on display in this seafaring tale, with unforgettable characters like Long John Silver remaining in our imaginations long after we’ve finished the book.

Expand full comment

I love your review. While P&P is not my favorite Austen novel, I do enjoy it. I also love when I can read a review that doesn't classify the novel as a "romance." I recently watched a YouTuber who read it for the first time and called it a romance novel. I yelled out that "It isn't a romance. It is so much more than a romance..." But, alas, she couldn't hear me.

Expand full comment