Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Dawn Camp's avatar

I remember reading Ficciones in college. Although I don’t remember the stories, I think they stretched my 18-year-old mind. I may pick this one up again. :)

Expand full comment
Felix Purat's avatar

Fascinating. Always wondered how things would pan out when Kodama passed. (May she rest in peace, although I didn't like that she was mean to Hurley; I liked the essayistic dimensions of his translations) As a writer, reader and Borges fan firstly, I don't object to her disregard of scholarly editions though: that only adds to the mystery, does it not? :-) As Kundera once wrote: "The Kafkologists have killed Kafka." A truth of which Borges was no doubt aware, given that he was kind of a kindred spirit of authors like Kafka.

I have to say it though: the "(shrug) it's a private company" argument when it comes to those estates is the same as surrender. It wouldn't be if there was nothing ideological whatsoever to do with these revisions. But it is completely ideological. It's a chess move where censorious believers in ideology take over unassailable terrain. This makes the situation no different from the Argentine state controlling Borges' works, except that different parties will have different needs. The ideological conquest of an estate, however, is total until a work enters the public domain. (And who's to say they won't pass laws preventing books from entering the public domain?)

Expand full comment
19 more comments...

No posts