15 Comments
User's avatar
Drake Greene's avatar

Derrick Jeter? What?! He could write and play baseball?! Oh, okay, a different Jeter.

There is a resurgence of interest in the literature of the West. The Manichaen sense of good and evil in many Western stories was relevant in the Cold War period and may be relevant again now.

Joel J Miller's avatar

Totally agree. And Manichaean is a great way to describe it.

Seth Tummins's avatar

Here in the East, everything gets pulled down into the earth. Stories are muffled and hushed beneath the fallen leaves and branches.

In the West, everything sits on the surface. Stories remain, if not the thing itself.

Jeff Cook-Coyle's avatar

Great stories and a great review.

Joel J Miller's avatar

Thanks, Jeff. They were fun books to read and write about. I actually read Gwyn’s twice. Both books recommended.

Jeff Cook-Coyle's avatar

I reposted your column twice. My compliment is sincere.

I also sent the column to a friend who is thinking of becoming a writer. What you describe: taking real events and mythologizing them; is what he’s been needing, conceptually, to get started.

Your simple definitions of the “what and why” of myths is tremendous. It’s like, “Aw, shit. I could do that.” If something comes of it (I won’t be surprised), I will definitely let you know.

Carol's avatar

I put these on my list. I loved McCormac’s trilogy but some of his others are hit and miss with me.

I tried to start The Ambassadors but having trouble getting into it. I may have to set it aside to another more opportune time for me. My mind is not in a good place for it right now. Sorry.

Joel J Miller's avatar

No worries on The Ambassadors. It’s a chore!

Derrick Jeter's avatar

Thank you so much, Joel. I’m grateful for the review—and to be included with Aaron’s work.

Joel J Miller's avatar

My pleasure! I enjoyed the book!

Richard Ritenbaugh's avatar

The American Mythos has been on my mind for many years. I agree that the West must be a huge part of it--in fact, our pioneering and exploring spirit is its heart. I'll have to put these books on my TBR list. Thanks for bringing them to my attention!

Joel J Miller's avatar

There’s so much richness and turmoil there. We’ll never exhaust it.

Melissa Miller's avatar

Maybe you’ve answered this before, but how do you decide what you are going to read next? And do you review all the books you read or just the ones you liked?